- Chart
- Upturn Summary
- Fund Details
Upturn AI Summary
First Trust Exchange-Traded Fund III - First Trust New York Municipal High Income ETF(FMNY)
Advisory History & Simulated Performance *
*as per simulation (see disclosures)- ALL
- 1Y
- 1M
- 1W
- BUY Advisory
- SELL Advisory (Profit)
- SELL Advisory (Loss)
- Profit
- Loss
- PASS (Skip)
Advisory Performance History (Simulated)
Upturn Advisory & Investor View for FMNY
11/20/2026: FMNY (1-star) has a low Upturn Star Rating. Not recommended to BUY.
First Trust New York Municipal High Income ETF (FMNY) provides actively managed exposure to New York municipal bonds, focusing on high-yield and tax-exempt income for investors subject to high state and local tax brackets. Its main strengths include professional active credit selection, monthly tax-free distributions, and targeted state-specific positioning. The fund serves primarily as a tax-advantaged income generator within a fixed-income allocation. Key risks involve a higher expense ratio (0.49%), lighter trading liquidity, interest rate sensitivity, and credit exposure to lower-rated local municipal issuers. It suits high-bracket New York taxpayers seeking enhanced tax-free yields, provided they monitor ongoing credit quality and liquidity metrics.
How to Read the Upturn Advisory
The Upturn Star Rating and the current BUY, SELL, or PASS advisory are generated by Upturn’s AI advisory engine based on proprietary signal analysis, price behavior, advisory history, and historical signal performance.
ETF holdings, costs, diversification, valuation, risks, and market conditions provide supporting context about the fund.
Investor Fit
| Investor style | Fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Growth investor | Weak fit | FMNY focuses on fixed-income yield rather than capital appreciation. |
| Momentum investor | Weak fit while signal remains positive | Municipal bond ETFs rarely exhibit the sharp upward momentum trends sought by active momentum traders. |
| Value investor | Mixed fit | Value investors seeking discounted fixed-income assets may appreciate tactical high-yield municipal pricing. |
| Dividend/Income investor | Strong fit | The fund is explicitly designed to deliver attractive, tax-exempt monthly income for high-bracket earners. |
| Low-risk investor | Medium | While municipal bonds are generally stable, FMNY's tilt toward high-income/lower-rated credit introduces moderate credit and volatility risks. |
Investor Profile
Ideal Investor Profile
High-net-worth individuals or residents of New York State and New York City subject to top tax brackets who prioritize tax-exempt current income over capital growth.
Suitability
Best suited for long-term income-focused investors comfortable with active management and slightly higher credit risk in exchange for tax-free yield.
Risk Profile
| Risk factor | Level | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Volatility | Low | The fund exhibits low historical beta and price volatility compared to broad equities. |
| Market risk | Medium | Changes in benchmark interest rates can impact the market value of the fund's underlying fixed-income holdings. |
| Concentration | High | Assets are geographically restricted exclusively to New York State municipal issuers. |
| Tracking/expense | Medium | An expense ratio of 0.49% introduces a notable fee drag relative to passive peers. |
| Liquidity | Medium / high | Lighter trading volumes can result in wider spreads during periods of market stress. |
| Business/sector quality | Medium | Exposure to lower-rated or unrated municipal revenue bonds increases credit default risk. |
Sector & Industry Intelligence
This fund is not assigned to one sector.
Risk Analysis
Volatility
FMNY maintains low price volatility typical of municipal bond strategies, though its high-yield credit tilt can experience slightly wider drawdowns during market stress.
Market Risk
Primary risks stem from interest rate fluctuations and credit default vulnerabilities tied directly to New York state and local municipal borrowers.
What the ETF Owns
| Exposure Type | Exposure | Weight (%) | Retail Investor Read |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed-income type | New York State Municipal Revenue and General Obligation Bonds | 96.34 | This core allocation drives the fund's tax-exempt distribution yield by investing in local high-yield and investment-grade municipal bonds. |
| Cash/collateral | Cash Equivalents and Short-Term Liquid Assets | 3.66 | Provides a minor liquidity buffer to manage portfolio rebalancing and distribution cash flows. |
Price Behavior

Downtrend
The stock has experienced a sustained decline in price over recent periods.

Very Smooth
The stock has followed a highly orderly price path with minimal short-term disruption.
Analysis of Past Performance
Type ETF | Historic Profit 3.63% | Avg. Invested days 40 | Today’s Advisory WEAK BUY |
Upturn Advisory Rating ![]() | Upturn Advisory Performance | ETF Returns Performance |

Note: This website is maintained by Upturn Corporation, which is an investment adviser registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Such registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Investing in securities has risks. Past performance is no guarantee of future returns. No assurance is provided as to any particular investment return, and you may lose money using our services. You are strongly advised to consult appropriate counsel before making any investments in companies you learn about through our services. You should obtain appropriate legal, tax, investment, accounting, and other advice that takes into account your investment portfolio and overall financial situation. You are solely responsible for conducting due diligence on a potential investment. We do not affect trades for you. You will select your own broker through which to transact. Investments are not FDIC insured, they are not guaranteed, and they may lose value. Please see the Privacy Policy, Terms of Use, and Disclosure for more information.
All company names, trademarks, logos, and brands are the property of their respective owners and are used for identification and informational purposes only. Use of these names, trademarks, and logos does not imply endorsement by their respective owners.

