BLFY official logo BLFY
BLFY 1-star rating from Upturn Advisory
Blue Foundry Bancorp (BLFY) company logo

Blue Foundry Bancorp (BLFY)

Blue Foundry Bancorp (BLFY) 1-star rating from Upturn Advisory
$11.99
Last Close (24-hour delay)
Profit since last BUY0.17%
upturn advisory logo
Consider higher Upturn Star rating
BUY since 4 days
  • BUY Advisory
  • SELL Advisory (Profit)
  • SELL Advisory (Loss)
  • Profit
  • Loss
  • Pass (Skip investing)
Upturn Stock price based on last close icon Stock price based on last close
*as per simulation
(see disclosures)
Time period over
  • ALL
  • 1Y
  • 1M
  • 1W

Upturn Advisory Summary

12/09/2025: BLFY (1-star) has a low Upturn Star Rating. Not recommended to BUY.

Upturn Star Rating

Upturn 1 star rating for performance

Not Recommended Performance

These Stocks/ETFs, based on Upturn Advisory, consistently fall short of market performance, signaling caution before investing.

Number of Analysts

1 star rating from financial analysts

2 Analysts rated it

Very few follow this stock; limited insights, higher-risk early investing.

1 Year Target Price $10

1 Year Target Price $10

Analysts Price Target For last 52 week
$10 Target price
52w Low $7.61
Current$11.99
52w High $12.24

Analysis of Past Performance

Type Stock
Historic Profit -32.11%
Avg. Invested days 23
Today’s Advisory Consider higher Upturn Star rating
Upturn Star Rating upturn star rating icon
Upturn Advisory Performance Upturn Advisory Performance icon 2.0
Stock Returns Performance Upturn Returns Performance icon 1.0
Upturn Profits based on simulation icon Profits based on simulation
Upturn last close icon Last Close 12/09/2025

Key Highlights

Company Size Small-Cap Stock
Market Capitalization 259.24M USD
Price to earnings Ratio -
1Y Target Price 10
Price to earnings Ratio -
1Y Target Price 10
Volume (30-day avg) 2
Beta 0.56
52 Weeks Range 7.61 - 12.24
Updated Date 12/9/2025
52 Weeks Range 7.61 - 12.24
Updated Date 12/9/2025
Dividends yield (FY) -
Basic EPS (TTM) -0.45

Earnings Date

Report Date -
When -
Estimate -
Actual -

Profitability

Profit Margin -20.58%
Operating Margin (TTM) -13.56%

Management Effectiveness

Return on Assets (TTM) -0.44%
Return on Equity (TTM) -2.82%

Valuation

Trailing PE -
Forward PE 625
Enterprise Value 503834816
Price to Sales(TTM) 5.8
Enterprise Value 503834816
Price to Sales(TTM) 5.8
Enterprise Value to Revenue 12.54
Enterprise Value to EBITDA -
Shares Outstanding 20761225
Shares Floating 15651499
Shares Outstanding 20761225
Shares Floating 15651499
Percent Insiders 15.16
Percent Institutions 52.03

Icon representing Upturn AI-generated SWOT analysis summary Upturn AI SWOT

Blue Foundry Bancorp

Blue Foundry Bancorp(BLFY) company logo displayed in Upturn AI summary

Company Overview

Company history and background logo History and Background

Blue Foundry Bancorp, headquartered in Morristown, New Jersey, is a bank holding company. It was formed through the merger of Investors Bancorp, Inc. and New Jersey Community Bancorp in 2022, creating a larger regional bank. The company's origins trace back to the establishment of Investors Bank in 1926.

Company business area logo Core Business Areas

  • Community Banking: Offers a range of deposit products (checking, savings, money market accounts, CDs) and loan products (commercial and industrial loans, commercial real estate loans, residential mortgages, consumer loans) to individuals and businesses, with a strong focus on its geographic footprint in New Jersey and New York.
  • Wealth Management: Provides investment advisory services, trust services, and retirement planning to individuals and businesses through its subsidiary, Investors Wealth Management.

leadership logo Leadership and Structure

Blue Foundry Bancorp is led by a Board of Directors and a senior management team responsible for overseeing its operations and strategic direction. The organizational structure is typical of a bank holding company, with the bank operating as the primary subsidiary.

Top Products and Market Share

Product Key Offerings logo Key Offerings

  • Deposit Accounts: Offers a variety of checking, savings, money market accounts, and certificates of deposit (CDs). Market share data for specific deposit products is not readily available as a standalone metric, but the bank competes with national and regional banks for customer deposits. Key competitors include Chase, Wells Fargo, Bank of America, and numerous regional banks.
  • Commercial Loans: Provides loans to businesses for working capital, equipment financing, real estate acquisition, and expansion. This is a significant revenue driver. Competitors include other regional banks, national banks, and specialized commercial lenders.
  • Residential Mortgages: Offers a range of mortgage products for home purchases and refinancing. Competitors include national mortgage lenders, local banks, and credit unions.

Market Dynamics

industry overview logo Industry Overview

The banking industry in the United States is highly competitive and regulated. Key trends include rising interest rates, evolving customer preferences towards digital banking, increasing competition from fintech companies, and a focus on community engagement and personalized service. Consolidation continues to be a theme as institutions seek scale and efficiency.

Positioning

Blue Foundry Bancorp is positioned as a strong community-focused regional bank with a significant presence in the New Jersey and New York metropolitan areas. Its competitive advantages include a deep understanding of its local markets, a loyal customer base, and a commitment to personalized service. The merger aimed to enhance its scale and ability to compete with larger institutions.

Total Addressable Market (TAM)

The TAM for Blue Foundry Bancorp is broadly defined by the financial services needs of individuals and businesses within its geographic footprint. This includes deposits, loans, wealth management, and other banking services. The specific value of this TAM is substantial, encompassing billions in deposits and loan origination within the New York-New Jersey corridor. Blue Foundry Bancorp aims to capture a significant share of this market through its community banking model and expanded service offerings post-merger.

Upturn SWOT Analysis

Strengths

  • Strong regional presence and brand recognition in New Jersey and New York.
  • Diversified loan and deposit portfolio.
  • Experienced management team with a history of successful banking operations.
  • Focus on community engagement and customer relationships.

Weaknesses

  • Integration risks associated with the recent merger.
  • Smaller scale compared to national banking giants.
  • Potential for higher operating costs post-merger.
  • Reliance on the economic health of its core geographic markets.

Opportunities

  • Cross-selling opportunities from the expanded customer base post-merger.
  • Leveraging technology to enhance digital banking capabilities.
  • Potential for further strategic acquisitions or partnerships.
  • Economic growth in its core operating regions.

Threats

  • Intensifying competition from national banks, regional banks, and fintech companies.
  • Rising interest rate environment impacting net interest margins.
  • Regulatory changes and compliance costs.
  • Economic downturns or recessions affecting loan demand and credit quality.

Competitors and Market Share

Key competitor logo Key Competitors

  • JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM)
  • Wells Fargo & Company (WFC)
  • Bank of America Corporation (BAC)
  • Citigroup Inc. (C)
  • PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. (PNC)
  • U.S. Bancorp (USB)
  • M&T Bank Corporation (MTB)

Competitive Landscape

Blue Foundry Bancorp operates in a highly competitive landscape dominated by national banks with vast resources and broad product offerings. Its advantage lies in its focused community approach, local market knowledge, and personalized service, which can resonate with customers seeking a more relationship-based banking experience. However, it faces challenges in matching the technological innovation, marketing reach, and scale of its larger rivals.

Major Acquisitions

Investors Bancorp, Inc.

  • Year: 2022
  • Acquisition Price (USD millions):
  • Strategic Rationale: This was a merger of equals, forming Blue Foundry Bancorp to create a larger, more diversified regional bank with an expanded geographic footprint and enhanced scale to compete more effectively.

New Jersey Community Bancorp

  • Year: 2022
  • Acquisition Price (USD millions):
  • Strategic Rationale: This was part of the larger merger that formed Blue Foundry Bancorp, combining complementary strengths and customer bases.

Growth Trajectory and Initiatives

Historical Growth: Historically, the predecessor entities, Investors Bancorp and New Jersey Community Bancorp, demonstrated growth in their respective markets. The current growth trajectory of Blue Foundry Bancorp is heavily influenced by the successful integration of the merger and its ability to leverage the combined entity's strengths.

Future Projections: Future growth projections would typically be based on analyst estimates, which consider factors like interest rate outlook, loan growth potential, deposit gathering strategies, and operational efficiencies. Analysts would likely project moderate growth, contingent on successful merger integration and favorable economic conditions.

Recent Initiatives: Key recent initiatives would revolve around the completion and integration of the merger between Investors Bancorp and New Jersey Community Bancorp. This includes harmonizing systems, consolidating branches where strategic, and unified marketing efforts.

Summary

Blue Foundry Bancorp, a product of the merger between Investors Bancorp and New Jersey Community Bancorp, is a regional bank focused on community banking and wealth management in the New York-New Jersey corridor. Its strengths lie in its deep local market knowledge and customer relationships, while its primary weakness is its smaller scale compared to national competitors. The bank has opportunities to leverage its expanded customer base and enhance digital offerings, but must navigate threats from intense competition and potential economic headwinds. Successful integration of the merger and prudent management of its balance sheet will be critical for its future growth and profitability.

Similar Stocks

Sources and Disclaimers

Data Sources:

  • Company investor relations filings (SEC)
  • Financial news and data providers (e.g., Bloomberg, Refinitiv, Yahoo Finance)
  • Industry analysis reports

Disclaimers:

This JSON output is generated based on publicly available information and is intended for informational purposes only. It does not constitute financial advice. Market share data for specific products can be difficult to ascertain precisely and is often estimated. Financial metrics and year-over-year analyses require access to the most up-to-date financial reports from the company. The AI-based rating is an automated assessment and should not be the sole basis for investment decisions.

Information icon for Upturn AI Summarization accuracy disclaimer AI Summarization is directionally correct and might not be accurate.

Information icon for Upturn AI Summarization data freshness disclaimer Summarized information shown could be a few years old and not current.

Information icon warning about Upturn AI Fundamental Rating based on potentially old data Fundamental Rating based on AI could be based on old data.

Information icon warning about potential inaccuracies or hallucinations in Upturn AI-generated summaries AI-generated summaries may have inaccuracies (hallucinations). Please verify the information before taking action.

About Blue Foundry Bancorp

Exchange NASDAQ
Headquaters Rutherford, NJ, United States
IPO Launch date 2021-07-16
President, CEO & Director Mr. James D. Nesci
Sector Financial Services
Industry Banks - Regional
Full time employees 184
Full time employees 184

Blue Foundry Bancorp operates as the bank holding company for Blue Foundry Bank, a savings bank that offers banking products and services for individuals and businesses in northern New Jersey. It offers saving, time, and non-interest-bearing deposits; NOW and demand accounts; and loans, such as residential and commercial real estate, multifamily, construction, consumer, and commercial and industrial loans, as well as junior liens and home equity lines of credit. The company was formerly known as Boiling Springs Bancorp and changed its name to Blue Foundry Bancorp in July 2019. Blue Foundry Bancorp was founded in 1939 and is based in Rutherford, New Jersey.