NI Holdings Inc logo

NI Holdings Inc(NODK)

upturn advisory logo
EXPLORE ADVISORIES AND THEIR HISTORY
QUALITY SIGNAL RECENCY
1-STAR RATING
SELL
SELL for 1 day
PROFIT SINCE LAST BUY
-4.08% ▼
LAST CLOSE
$14.83
11/20/2026
(24-hour delay)

Advisory History & Simulated Performance *

*as per simulation (see disclosures)
  • ALL
  • 1Y
  • 1M
  • 1W
  • BUY Advisory
  • SELL Advisory (Profit)
  • SELL Advisory (Loss)
  • Profit
  • Loss
  • PASS (Skip)
Upturn Stock price based on last close iconStock price based on last close
Simulated performance—not actual client returns. Excludes advisory subscription fees, trading commissions, and taxes, which would reduce returns. Results depend on calculation assumptions and do not guarantee future outcomes. See Disclosures for full methodology, assumptions, and limitations.

Advisory Performance History (Simulated)Advisory Performance History info

Simulated performance—not actual client returns. Excludes advisory subscription fees, trading commissions, and taxes, which would reduce returns. Results depend on calculation assumptions and do not guarantee future outcomes. See Disclosures for full methodology, assumptions, and limitations.

Upturn Advisory & Investor View for NODK

11/20/2026: NODK (1-star) is a SELL. SELL for 1 day. Simulated Profits (-4.08%). Updated daily EoD!

NI Holdings Inc is a regional property and casualty insurance holding company that underwrites auto, home, farm, and crop insurance primarily in the Upper Midwest. The company's main strengths lie in its established brand loyalty, specialized agricultural expertise, and stable majority-controlled corporate structure. Its core growth opportunity centers on selective geographic expansion and digital workflow enhancements, though performance remains vulnerable to severe weather events and claims cost inflation. Financial results can fluctuate due to catastrophe losses, and the stock does not currently pay a dividend, making it most suitable for value-oriented investors willing to monitor regional underwriting cycles. Key developments to track include weather-related loss trends, pricing adequacy adjustments, and operational expense ratios.

How to Read the Upturn Advisory

The Upturn Star Rating and the current BUY, SELL, or PASS advisory are generated by Upturn’s AI advisory engine based on proprietary signal analysis, price behavior, advisory history, and historical signal performance.

Company fundamentals, valuation, risks, and news provide supporting context about the business.

Investor Fit

Investor styleFitWhy
Growth investorMixed fitRevenue growth has been cyclical and constrained by regional market boundaries.
Momentum investorWeak fitLow trading volume and modest short-term price movement offer limited momentum appeal.
Value investorMixed fitThe stock trades near its book value base, but intermittent underwriting losses warrant caution.
Dividend investorWeak fitThe company does not pay a cash dividend, focusing instead on capital retention.
Low-risk investorMixed fitWhile beta is low, vulnerability to weather and catastrophe losses introduces earnings volatility.

Risk Profile

Risk factorLevelWhy it matters
Price volatilityLowThin trading volumes and low equity beta limit sharp daily price swings.
Valuation riskMediumValuation aligns closely with book value but remains sensitive to earnings downturns.
Competition risk (name the main competitor theme, e.g. AI competition)Medium / highRegional property and casualty lines face pricing pressure from larger tech-enabled national insurers.
Business qualityMediumSolid regional franchise history is occasionally impacted by weather-driven loss spikes.
Dividend incomeLow / noneAbsence of dividend payouts provides zero immediate income return for shareholders.
Execution riskMediumManagement must successfully navigate underwriting discipline and inflationary claims costs.

Key Highlights

Company Size Small-Cap Stock
Market Capitalization 301.19M USD
Price to earnings Ratio 20.6
1Y Target Price -
Price to earnings Ratio 20.6
1Y Target Price -
Volume (30-day avg) 16.5K shares
Beta 0.24
52 Weeks Range 12.37 - 16.70
Updated Date 11/21/2026
52 Weeks Range 12.37 - 16.70
Updated Date 11/21/2026
Dividends yield (FY) -
Basic EPS (TTM) 0.72

Sector & Industry Intelligence

Sector

Financial Services

Caution
Sentiment
Weak Bullish
Momentum
BUY Breadth Lower
BUY participation
30.8%
Active BUY / eligible
28 / 91
30-Day BUY Count Change
+13
Market state
Weak Bullish

Qualifying BUY stocks have fallen well below recent levels and have not recovered.

Industry

Insurance - Property & Casualty

BUY participation
60.0%
Active BUY / eligible
3 / 5
30-Day BUY Count Change
+1

Eligible universe: 5 stocks.

Sector signal summarizes BUY breadth conditions for the sector. It does not override this stock’s BUY, SELL, or PASS advisory.

Price Behavior

Strong Uptrend
PRICE PATH

Strong Uptrend

The stock has maintained a strong upward price trend across the last three quarters.

Smooth
PRICE STABILITY

Smooth

The stock has moved along a generally orderly path with only modest fluctuations.

Analysis of Past Performance

Type Stock
Historic Profit 11.73%
Avg. Invested days 72
Today’s Advisory SELL
Upturn Advisory Rating upturn star rating icon
Upturn Advisory Performance Upturn Advisory Performance icon 3.0
Stock Returns Performance Upturn Returns Performance icon 2.0
Upturn Profits based on simulation icon Profits based on simulation
Upturn last close icon Last Close 11/20/2026

Upturn Scorecard

Upturn Star Rating

★★★★★
NODK receives a 2-star rating, reflecting soft or weak scores across the available pillars. The rating is constrained by weak unit economics, soft company fundamentals, and soft analyst coverage.

Company Fundamentals

★★★★★
NODK has soft overall fundamentals (2 stars), with soft financial health, soft growth momentum, and moderate ownership. In FY2025 versus FY2024, growth and ownership metrics are mixed: negative earnings growth (-71.8%), weak cash generation (FCF margin -5.4%), negative revenue growth (-12.3%).

Financial Health Rating

★★★★★
NODK's financial health is soft, with the relatively strongest area being moderate efficiency, including operating-expense and cost-of-revenue discipline (opex 33.9% of revenue). Profitability is soft (2 stars), which helps explain the 2-star overall score.

Growth Momentum Score

★★★★★
NODK's growth profile is soft, with the least-weak measure being revenue growth at -12.3% FY2025 versus FY2024. By comparison, while earnings growth (-71.8%, negative) and free-cash-flow growth (-190.7%, negative) hold the profile back, so recent growth is not broad-based across the business.

Ownership

★★★★★
Institutional ownership is 24.7% (moderate) and 29.1% of outstanding shares are publicly tradable (soft). Insider ownership of 63.90% supports management-shareholder alignment.

Top 5 Institutional Investors

M3F, Inc. 7.89%
Newtyn Management LLC 3.30%
BlackRock Inc 2.69%
Dimensional Fund Advisors, Inc. 1.84%
Vanguard Capital Management, LLC 1.42%

Unit Economics (Per $1K Revenue)

★★★★★
NODK generates approximately $296 of gross profit, $-43 of operating income, and $-54 of free cash flow for every $1,000 of revenue. Based on FY2025 results. Operating losses and cash burn explain the 1-star rating, with weak cash conversion and weak capital efficiency.

Economic Dimensions

★★★★★
Effective Tax Rate: 15.54%

Quantitative Style Profile

★★★★★
NODK has a relatively low-volatility profile. Weak momentum is the primary drawback.

Style Classification

Quality Focused

Value-OrientedLow VolatilitySmall / Mid Cap Risk

How Company Makes Money

Business areaWhat it includesRetail investor read
Private Passenger & Non-Standard AutoStandard and minimum-limit auto liability and physical damage insurance policies.Generates steady premium income from vehicle owners, though auto claims inflation can squeeze margins.
Home and Farm InsuranceProperty and liability coverage for homes, rural properties, and agricultural operations.Provides core regional revenues, though severe weather events can cause periodic earnings shocks.
Crop InsuranceFederal multi-peril and private crop-hail insurance lines.Links a portion of top-line performance directly to agricultural harvest and weather conditions.

Earnings Date

Report Date 2026-11-06
When After Market
Estimate -
Actual 0.27

Profitability

Profit Margin 5.79%
Operating Margin (TTM) 7.73%

Management Effectiveness

Return on Assets (TTM) 2.4%
Return on Equity (TTM) 6.15%

Valuation

Trailing PE 20.6
Forward PE -
Enterprise Value 254.33M
Price to Sales(TTM) 1.16
Enterprise Value 254.33M
Price to Sales(TTM) 1.16
Enterprise Value to Revenue 1
Enterprise Value to EBITDA -
Shares Outstanding 20.31M
Shares Floating 5.90M
Shares Outstanding 20.31M
Shares Floating 5.90M
Percent Insiders 63.9
Percent Institutions 24.68

Financial Metrics

🧭 Investment Snapshot

Total Revenue (Scale)

Information icon Total money earned from selling products or services before any costs. It is needed to understand the scale of the business and its ability to generate income.

Net Income (Profit)

Information icon Final profit after all expenses, interest, and taxes are deducted. It is needed to determine the overall profitability available to shareholders.

Free Cash Flow (Cash Strength)

Information icon Cash remaining after operating activities and capital expenditures, showing cash available for growth. It is needed to evaluate the company’s ability to invest, pay dividends, or reduce debt.

📈 Growth & Strength

Operating Income (Core Profit)

Information icon Profit from core operations after deducting all operating expenses. It is needed to measure how efficiently the company runs its primary business activities.

EBITDA (Cash Earnings)

Information icon Earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization, indicating operating cash potential. It is needed to compare operating performance across companies without accounting or financing differences.

Gross Profit (Unit Profitability)

Information icon Revenue minus cost of revenue, showing profit after direct production costs. It is needed to evaluate core business profitability before overhead expenses.

🛡️ Financial Safety

Cash (Liquidity Buffer)

Information icon Total cash and cash equivalents on hand. It is needed to evaluate immediate liquidity and financial flexibility.

Total Debt (Leverage Risk)

Information icon Total debt including both short-term and long-term components. It is needed to assess the company’s leverage and financial risk.

Net Working Capital (Short-Term Health)

Information icon Current assets minus current liabilities, indicating short-term liquidity strength. It is needed to assess whether the company can meet its short-term obligations.

🧱 Balance Sheet Strength

Stockholder Equity (Net Worth)

Information icon Total equity value held by shareholders. It is needed to understand the net worth of the company from the owners’ perspective.

Total Assets (Asset Base)

Information icon The full value of everything the company owns, including cash, inventory, equipment, and investments. It is needed to understand the resource base used to generate revenue.

Income Before Tax (Pre-Tax Earnings)

Information icon Income before provision for income taxes. It is needed to analyze profitability independent of tax structures.

⚙️ Cost & Drag Factors

Cost of Revenue (Production Cost)

Information icon Direct costs required to produce and deliver the products or services sold. It is needed to assess efficiency in production and service delivery.

Total Operating Expenses (Operating Cost)

Information icon Indirect costs of running the business such as salaries, marketing, and administration. It is needed to understand how much it costs to sustain ongoing business operations.

Income Tax Expense (Tax Drag)

Information icon Amount of taxes paid or payable to the government. It is needed to evaluate the impact of taxation on overall profitability.

Form CRS provides a relationship summary of our automated advisory services, flat subscription fees, and conflicts of interest. Form ADV Part 2A brochure contains complete details on services, billing, and disclosures. If any summary differs from our current regulatory filings, the filed Form ADV controls.